Current:Home > NewsFuture of Texas’ migrant-blocking buoys may hinge on whether the Rio Grande is ‘navigable’ -FundSphere
Future of Texas’ migrant-blocking buoys may hinge on whether the Rio Grande is ‘navigable’
View
Date:2025-04-22 07:38:13
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — The future of a barrier of giant buoys that Texas Gov. Greg Abbot placed in the Rio Grande last year to deter migrant traffic may turn on whether a rocky, shallow stretch of the border river can be considered “navigable” and whether immigration sometimes constitutes a hostile invasion.
The full 17-member 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments on the issues in New Orleans on Wednesday, the latest courtroom debate in multiple legal disputes over border control between Democratic President Joe Biden and the Republican governor. The judges did not indicate when they would rule.
Part of the hearing touched on Texas’ claim that the barrier is authorized constitutionally as a means of defending against an invasion.
“Are you saying that federal law overcomes the constitutional right of the state?” Judge Edith Jones asked Justice Department attorney Michael Gray. She later added: “Under what circumstances can the United States thwart that attempt at self-defense?”
In response to questions from Jones and Judge James Ho, Gray argued that a governor cannot get around federal law simply by claiming an invasion. “Their argument is, once they say invasion ‘We can do anything we want for as long as we want.’ We don’t think that’s right,” Gray said.
But much of the hearing dealt with whether the administration was correct that the Rio Grande is subject to federal regulation as a navigable waterway.
Texas says the stretch of river is rocky and shallow — describing it as “ankle deep” in one filing.
“For most of its length and much of its storied history, the Rio Grande has been little more than a creek with an excellent publicist,” Lanora Pettit, with Texas Attorney General’s Office said.
The Biden administration has pointed to past ferry traffic in the area, the use of the area by vessels with the U.S. Coast Guard and the International Boundary and Water Commission and the possibility of future projects to make the stretch better suited for commercial traffic.
The state installed the orange, wrecking ball-sized buoys last July. The barrier stretches about 1000 feet (304 meters) along the international border with Mexico between the Texas border city of Eagle Pass and Piedras Negras, Coahuila.
In December, a divided panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had sided with a federal district judge in Texas who said the buoys must be moved. But the panel’s 2-1 ruling after was vacated in January when a majority of the conservative-dominated court’s 17 active judges voted to rehear the case. An 18th judge who is on part-time senior status and was on the three-member panel also participated with the full court Wednesday.
The Biden administration also is fighting for the right to cut razor-wire fencing at the border and for access to a city park at the border that the state fenced off.
And a decision is pending from a 5th Circuit panel on whether to allow Texas to enforce a law that allows any Texas law enforcement officer to arrest people suspected of entering the country illegally.
veryGood! (376)
Related
- Taylor Swift makes surprise visit to Kansas City children’s hospital
- Yankees don't have time to lick their wounds after gut-punch Game 3 loss
- 'Lifesaver': How iPhone's satellite mode helped during Hurricane Helene
- Harris and Trump target Michigan as both parties try to shore up ‘blue wall’ votes
- Everything Simone Biles did at the Paris Olympics was amplified. She thrived in the spotlight
- Liam Payne was 'intoxicated,' 'breaking the whole room' before death from fall: 911 call
- Nordstrom Rack's Top 100 Fall Deals: Your Guide to Can't-Miss Discounts, Including $11.98 Sweaters
- Nordstrom Rack's Top 100 Fall Deals: Your Guide to Can't-Miss Discounts, Including $11.98 Sweaters
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Indian government employee charged in foiled murder-for-hire plot in New York City
Ranking
- Paris Olympics live updates: Quincy Hall wins 400m thriller; USA women's hoops in action
- A man has been charged with murder in connection with an Alabama shooting that left 4 dead
- A father and son are both indicted on murder charges in a mass school shooting in Georgia
- NFL trade candidates: 16 players who could be on the block ahead of 2024 deadline
- $1 Frostys: Wendy's celebrates end of summer with sweet deal
- A man has been charged with murder in connection with an Alabama shooting that left 4 dead
- Takeaways from The Associated Press’ reporting on extremism in the military
- McConnell called Trump ‘stupid’ and ‘despicable’ in private after the 2020 election, a new book says
Recommendation
Connie Chiume, Black Panther Actress, Dead at 72: Lupita Nyong'o and More Pay Tribute
Liam Payne was open about addiction. What he told USA TODAY about alcohol, One Direction
Liam Payne was 'intoxicated,' 'breaking the whole room' before death from fall: 911 call
'Lifesaver': How iPhone's satellite mode helped during Hurricane Helene
Audit: California risked millions in homelessness funds due to poor anti-fraud protections
Indian government employee charged in foiled murder-for-hire plot in New York City
Disney x Kate Spade’s Snow White Collection Is the Fairest of Them All -- And It's on Sale
We Are Ranking All of Zac Efron's Movies—You Can Bet On Having Feelings About It